from pages 213-215 of Allsville Emerging (http://sbpra.com/DarrellMoneyhon):
..."Rural" may, for many, represent the informal
means of living, solving problems, and of making meaning.
Neuropsychologically speaking, the right brain hemisphere
seems to specialize in a more impressionistic, informal
means by which to live, solve problems, and to make meaning.
The left brain hemisphere seems to specialize in a more
formal, keeping-ducks-in-a-row, approach to living, solving
problems, and making meaning.
Over time, groups of people may simply associate the
informal, right brain, mode with a rural lifestyle and subculture.
The big city may be associated with more formal
reasoning. Certainly more highly organized methods are
needed in large and dense populations. More formalized
rules, regulations, and systems are needed in the big city.
How much of this formalization is due to plain old reality,
and how much is attributable to compensating for dehumanizing
effects that cause people to be increasingly willing to
violate one another, is not known.
But few would argue against the notion that more technical
and formal reasoning is needed to orchestrate a city
than is needed for a small burg or farm community. And few
would suggest that it would be a good idea to run a rural
community like you would a big city. Different ways for different
landscapes. You wouldn’t use a plow on a city street,
nor a street sweeper on tilled ground.
According to a branch of psychology called “attribution
theory,” the following might be occuring. We might associate
the neuropsychological mode of the left brain (and its
leaning toward formal ways of doing things) to the city way
of life (or big government or big business). The mental association
can be so strong that we think the city caused the
problem of being overly formal, cold, or dehumanizing. In
our minds the city represents formality. The formal (left
brain hemisphere) mode and the big city (and/or big business,
and/or big government) are more-or-less one and the
same. That is our “attribution.” We think that big city living
caused the paint-by-numbers formality. To the extent
that this is not true (What about the informal self expression
that took place in inner city coffee houses during the beatnik
movement?), then the attribution is a misattribution. We tend
to misattribute city life/society to formality and to formal
reasoning, etc.
Associating rural with informal, right brain, approaches
is another attribution. We assume that rural living somehow
causes the informal mode that we need in order to be
free flowing, warmly received, human beings. But is this the
whole truth? Anyone who has actually lived for an extended
period in a rural community can tell you that plenty of role-rigid
ways and norms which appear quite formal and moralistic
exist in the so-called “laid back” rural and small town
culture. That testimony reveals a degree of misattribution.
Rural is not always laid back or informal. Nor is it always
“warm and friendly.” There is nothing warm and friendly
about small town gossip.
But because many people equivocate (incorrectly assume
an equivalence between two or more things) the rural way of
life with the informal mode, and because they further mistake
the informal mode itself as being the whole “answer”
to our social problems, those folks often become politically
active (usually on the “right”). They try to make the world in
the image of a rural community, instead of trying to discover
a more appropriate, workable, way to bring the informal
mode back into formalized systems.
Instead of trying to plow, or “plow down,” city streets and
government agencies, it would be more effective to fight to
integrate formal and informal ways/modes. The question we
need to ask is “How can we develop complex systems that
effectively serve humans, and that allow humans to feel like
human beings instead of like servants of cold and complicated
systems?” No doubt, the dynamics of urban/rural are
real. But there seems to be this deeper dynamic that we need
to understand before we can manifest a more harmonious
world. And that dynamic may play out largely in the space
between our ears—in the relationship between our left and
right brain hemispheres.
No comments:
Post a Comment