Monday, May 21, 2012

Ten Commandments of Collective Living


Allsville's Ten Commandments  (developed after publication of Allsville Emerging ; http://sbpra.com/DarrellMoneyhon):

1. Thou shalt base the collective's operations upon a deep, transpersonal, originating point. 
2. Thou shalt strive to unfold individual and collective potentials. 
3. Thou shalt sense other in self, self in other, and care for one another accordingly. 
4. Thou shalt recognize, cherish, and develop the gifts in, of, and through existence, especially "human gifts." 
5. Thou shalt locate and dissolve obstacles to growing and flowing.
6. Thou shalt develop and continuously refine an integrated system for optimal collective living. 
7. Thou shalt safely conduct experiments in government, seeing what works and what doesn't work. 
8. Thou shalt share resources. 
9. Thou shalt use continuous quality improvement. 
10. Thou shalt incorporate on the scale of village, tribe, or town.

These traditionally-inspired "commandments" are of course no longer the authoritarian commandments of old, but more like modern "mission statements" that manifest themselves via articulation, inspiration, and application. They help structure our space station. 

Friday, May 18, 2012

Suffering as "Teleological Opportunity"


from pages 397-402 of Allsville Emerging (http://sbpra.com/DarrellMoneyhon):

Practice: Conceptualize and utilize“Teleological Opportunities”—a spiritual approach to correction and restoration.


Another thought adopted by the FSDM is the concept of
“teleological opportunity.” Both the offender and the victim
have a chance to grow from the pain of the tragic misbehavior.
This does in no way mean that the pain and resistance
to change can be treated lightly. The pain caused to victims
cannot be minimized. The pain is real, and victims need others
to understand that—not to gloss over it. Victims do need
empathy.
   And, ultimately, a wrongdoer is his or her own victim as
well. Wrongdoing leaves you broken and contaminated. Both
the victim and the offender have a considerable struggle that
they must pass through before the growth opportunity can
become apparent.
   But the official view of Allsville is that whole-mindedness,
or “God,” is pulling us toward higher stages of understanding
and being. The evolutionary movement is usually slow, but
the suffering can be an opportunity to be pulled faster toward
wholeness, toward God.
   The reason that suffering can (with emphasis on the word
can) be a chance to move forward, rather than backward—
upward, rather than sinking in the heaviness of sinful or
wounded “flesh”—is that during suffering, the status quo
structure of self is broken up. The structure of self is momentarily
broken for both victim and offender.
   While it’s easy to see how the victim is shattered, it is
less clear how the offender is shattered. The offender’s self
structure is broken because he or she has to face his/her own
monster, sin nature, or dark side. However, this facing of
one’s dark side may not be the case for those with significant
sociopathy, which numbs them to any trauma of seeing
themselves as a social “minus.”
   In the relatively rare cases of high degrees of sociopathy,
the correction must attempt to use the “seeing” function
of the mind of the offender, in order to eventually get to
the heart (and to a “place” called love). The sociopath is so
detached from the heart that the seeing mind of the hunter
must be used as the means to navigate toward a vision of
interconnectedness. Once the vision of interconnectedness
has been “caught” via the (mental) hunting process, then the
offender is much more likely to see that love and empathy
“make sense.”
   Then it may be possible for the mind to open up into
heart—into a newfound capacity to love. The soul function
(the branch of spirit that has to do with peaceful acceptance
and with simply, fully, being) can be activated/facilitated in
order to assist the sociopath in his or her hunt for truth, but
it is important to bypass the heart branch of spirit during the
early parts of the correction process.
   Why? Because the consummate hunter/sociopath would
only posture love, and would use it to appear to have changed.
Trying to teach empathy to a sociopath is only giving him or
her more tips for successful acting. Many a sociopath has
learned to win Oscars in social situations. They can master
the role of acting like a warm and loving person. That is why
some of them are called “con artists.”
   To avoid teaching the sociopath how to act better, the
heart branch of spirit must be visited later on, after the hunt
for a vision of interconnection or wholeness has been successful.
Waiting until that time is another application of PIC.
   In the case of a person with a high degree of sociopathy, out
of phase interventions for empathy will do more harm than
good. All we would get is crocodile tears that would fool us
into thinking correction has occurred.
   Again, the heart branch of spirit must be activated much
later, after the mind branch of spirit “sees” deeply enough to
be at a place closer to the core of the self (a more spiritual,
energy-based, zone), where switchover from one branch to
another is easier. The branches of spirit are more naturally
convergent toward the core. If the hunter has not mentally
migrated deep enough into the inner wilderness as he or she
hunts for the truth, then his or her transformative capacity
simply won’t be there yet.
   Fortunately, the mind’s seeing tends to pull the soul along.
Even a hunter with good eyes and good rifles has a limit as to
how far away he or she can be from the thing being hunted.
The hunter must stand or camp close enough to the prey.
This limitation ends up being a good thing when it comes
to correction, because the soul will temporarily locate in the
deeper zones of spirit while the sociopath hunts down the
truth.
   Also, the hunter/sociopath has plenty of pride to motivate
him or her to press further toward hunting down the truth. To
be given credit for only superficial truths would be an insult
of being “weak minded.” It would be like recognizing the
hunter for bringing home a little rabbit, when the buffalo or
bear is what is most prized. The motivation for a sociopath
must be to realize the full strength of his or her mind.
   Fortunately (again), when the mind is at its greatest strength
it is also at its lowest resistance. Ultimately, openness is required
in order to achieve optimal ability, or “strength.” Flow
marries force. A masterful child is born. The hunt transforms
the hunter at the point when the mind realizes its fullest capacity.
“Seeing” yields to “being” and to “love.” Once the
sociopath catches the truest truth, then the hunted captures
the hunter, and then (and only then) can the sociopath find
love. “And only then” is one reason why phased correction
is so important.
   Back to the offender who is not a sociopath (most aren’t):
The suffering that occurs when a person faces his or her own
failure, shame, remorse, and dark side, can interrupt the
comfortable state of equilibrium of the self, and can allow
the individual to “soul search” (go deeper into spirit). This
is the penitence process. The word penitentiary comes from
the word penitence.
   True correction does require penitence, but it may not be
sufficient to simply isolate a person in a dark cell, and sit
back and wait for them to achieve penitence. Suffering is
most therapeutic when a guide is there to help the offender
face and work through the suffering—when someone is there
to encourage the offender to soul search.
   The same support and guidance must be offered to the
victims of the offense. The victim can’t be rushed to forgive.
It would do more harm than good. The suffering
process must work through the emotions of hurt, loss, depression,
and anger first, before getting (if ever) to the point
of forgiveness.
   Again, a phased approach is needed. But forgiveness can
be a healthy long range goal that represents the ultimate liberation
from victimization. If the soul search goes well, the
individual (whether the offender or the offended) learns to
operate more from an inner spiritual core. “When rough is
the course, we turn to the Source.” Or at least we have the
opportunity to do so.
   In general, Allsvillites tend to agree with Jeremy. They believe
that this spiritual core—what Jeremy calls the “Continuously
Unfolding Spiritual Source,” or CUSS (lending itself
to the motto: “Don’t take the Lord’s name in vain, CUSS!”)
is of an energy (or energy field) nature. And since this energy
is seen as an ultimately more real aspect of physical
existence, then it is seen as an essence, or as the “spirit,” of
being. As such, the harnessing of this nature represents a better—
higher—way of being.
   Loss and suffering, although very painful to our flesh’s
various dependencies or attachments (and these dependencies
are not necessarily wrong or bad, but just less complete
than the power and potentials that we could have, or will have
“by and by”), is an opportunity to realign with the innermost
energy core. To the extent that this realignment can be
converted to everyday living, long after the tragedy has been
dealt with, then the person has grown spiritually. The person
is operating at a higher stage of being and consciousness.
   Thus, all suffering involves a paradox. Suffering constitutes
both an excruciating pain and a “Teleological Opportunity”
(TO). Suffering, if seen in just the right (optimal) way,
is an opportunity to be pulled closer to God.
   This in no way means that you congratulate victims for
their suffering. To the contrary, you must join with them in
their suffering. A big part of the way to help sufferers utilize
TO is to have empathy, care, and love toward them.
   In the case of the offender, we may need to help them
peel the onion back from callused emotional reactions (of
bitterness, anger, power obsession, denial, or minimization),
in order to help the offender eventually “own” his or her suffering,
whether that suffering is in the form of remorse, or in
the form of other unresolved sufferings/traumas which may
have contributed to the wrongdoing.
   Working through the suffering leads to love because the
working through process itself is actually an act of love.
When it comes to facing and working through suffering, the
journey is the destination.
   Like a gardener who loves her garden, and lovingly waters
and weeds it daily, the person who loves herself will work
through suffering, in order to get beyond it. Walking around
pretending that the weeds or the dry conditions of suppressed
(or repressed) suffering don’t exist is not an option for the
person who loves the “garden” called “self.”
   Stated differently (switching metaphors), Love is a highway
to God, even when the personal path is unbelievably
harsh.
   Love is the heart’s action for healing. The mind’s action
is seeing/understanding the teleological opportunity that lies
hidden in the suffering. Those who see it can help others see
it, as long as the understanding is accompanied with compassion.
Lecturing won’t help. Information without a process
won’t help. But a compassionate heart and a wise head
can come together to help the sufferer grow spiritually.
   The shorthand version of this particular social regulation
approach is: “The FSDM intends to use PIC to utilize TO.”
Each new council member will be taught this formula, and
will be assisted in developing a deep understanding of it.




Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Allsville's Inside-Out Philosophy



from pages 192-198 of Allsville Emerging (http://sbpra.com/DarrellMoneyhon): 

A proposed step toward building this common ground is
to have the model communities’ citizens agree upon a different
cultural/theological paradigm than the one by which
most of the modern world is currently operating. We can’t
simply stick a bunch of different religious groups together
if we don’t have a common paradigm by which to orchestrate
cooperation, and by which we can detect drift from the
common ground. Two thinkers come to mind as offering a
healthy alternative to the current modern cultural paradigm.
One of the thinkers is Stephen Covey. The other is Dr. Na’im
Akbar.
   Covey begins his book, The Seven Habits of Highly Effective
People, with a chapter called “Inside-Out.” He goes on
to relate a personal experience which led him to this belief.
He and his wife discovered that one of their sons responded
much more favorably when they learned to listen to his own
unique gifts and motives. Their earlier attempts to “fix” him
with outside-in approaches had simply lowered his self esteem
and were interfering with his abilities. When they, as
parents, changed their whole approach to nurturing his (inner)
gifts, he blossomed. Covey says that his wife and he had
shifted “paradigms” from “outside-in” to “inside-out.” He
then goes on to emphasize the long range effectiveness of
building one’s own inner “character,” as opposed to individuals
attempting to adopt the more superficial “personality”
change techniques. He sees those personality change techniques
as being part of an outside-in paradigm. His seven
effective habits rely upon the understanding and adoption of
the inside-out viewpoint/paradigm.
   Dr. Na’im Akbar , in his book The Community of Self, emphasizes
the need to “listen to the inner voices.” The “inner
voice” is a source of psychological freedom. Although the
following passage from that book is addressing the African
American community in the United States, it applies to any
citizen in any nation influenced culturally by a global market
that creates consumers who are conditioned to fit the needs
of that market system. Both the African American victim of
the stubborn social and psychological aftereffects of slavery,
and the transracial “consumer slave” lack the freedom to be
governed by the “inner voice.”


        The problem that faces us in the second century after
        political emancipation is the need for psychological
        emancipation. We have not regained our freedom because
        we have not learned to listen to the inner voice
        of ourselves. We still listen only to the ideas, interpretations,
        explanations, and directions that are given
        to us from outside of our communities. Of course,
        that outer voice, like all the outer influences, is much
        louder—so it usually drowns out the small voice of
        freedom from within that has been stifled for almost
        400 years. It is not an easy thing to hear the inner
        community voice, but freedom does not come until
        we hear it.
            It is, therefore, necessary to turn off the outer influences
        in much the same way that , individually,
        we must turn off the radios and televisions that drive
        us away from freedom. We must identify the independent
        voice that comes from ourselves in order to
        locate the road to freedom. . . .



This is an inside-out model for building a healthy community.
Such a model believes in the patterns deep within,
that will ultimately govern each person, as well as groups
of people. Todd noticed a similarity between this belief and
Taoism. According to Hyun Hochsmann and Yang Guorong,
in their book, Zhuangzi (which introduces and translates the
writings of Zhuangzi, a prominent Taoist), Taoism had an affinity
to Confucius’ Doctrine of the Mean.
   In that writing, Confucius said, “He who is sincere is one
who hits upon what is right without effort and apprehends
without thinking. He is naturally and easily in harmony with
the Way.” For Todd, this “sincerity” implies “listening” to a
voice/sense from the innermost core of self that is in unity
with all things. This guiding sense from deep within constitutes
the ineffable Tao (the Way).
   But one must go deep enough. If he or she goes only part
way in, then the inner voice will be distorted. At times, we
may mistake strong inner drives as the source of the inner
voices. This mistake sets the stage for the following debate.

Listening to the Heart, Deeply
Invariably, during philosophical discussions about the wisdom
of listening to one’s heart, someone mentions how the
heart can make a person do impulsive and foolish things,
such as killing another person when finding one’s lover engaged
in an act of infidelity. The crime of passion is often
attributed to listening to the heart. The discussion usually
results in a declaration that the disagreement of whether to
listen to the heart or not is a result of semantics regarding the
meaning of “heart.”
   Generally, there are two distinctions made by the proponents
of listening to the heart. One distinction is that reacting
to the heart (as in the above example of a crime of passion)
is different than really listening. To this argument, the proponents
of not listening to the heart, counter with something
like, “But my broken heart would say to kill the man who is
cheating with my lover; that’s why I shouldn’t listen to my
heart.”
   The other distinction made by the listen-to-the-heart camp
is that one must go deep within the heart to get the correct
guidance. The impulse to kill is seen as being from a shallow
part of what is being called “the heart,” not the true heart
(center/core) of the self. This distinction (of deep vs. shallow)
is where the semantics problem comes into play. Which
“heart” are we talking about? The jealous and possessive
one that the listen-to-the-heart camp attributes to the shallow
pseudo-heart? Or the “true” heart deep within?
   Todd believed that Dr. Akbar would agree with the latter
version. Akbar makes it clear that he is not talking about
instinctual and appetitive “drive” as being the inner part that
governs. To the contrary, he identifies the need for an individual
to override his or her individual drives with a higher
governing principle. Those appetitive, and fear-avoidant
drives can block out the inner voice as much as outer distractions
block it out. In fact, he maintains that the modern
market culture’s advertisements and sales techniques are engineered
to activate and exploit those internal drives.
   Once these drives are activated, the managing part of the
personality called the “ego” must be constantly engaged, in
order to figure out a way to best meet or suppress/control
those wants. To the extent that the ego is busy tending to
those drives, then the self cannot connect with the innermost
part (or mode), and can no longer fully operate in an insideout
manner. The ego, being geared to actively seek particular
and more immediate practical solutions (in order to make
sure the job gets done sometime soon, as opposed to giving
priority to eventual growth), tends to look for external things
it can use to either meet or control the wants.
   “External things” may include other people. The ego tends
to view people as objects; perhaps very valuable objects, but
objects nonetheless. A society that activates ego a lot tends
to eventually turn even its own human beings into “capital”
that is to be used in order to meet the perceived needs or
wants of whoever manages to gain the most control of the
available resources, human or otherwise.
   Todd saw the innermost realm of mind or self as being
beyond the defensive, rational, and practical ego functions
of the personality. Not only does the deeper realm, or state,
appear to be free to explore a wider range of experience patterns
and truths than does the ego, it also appears to be free
of the duality of self and other. Perhaps that which is deep
inside is a form of fine, low resistance, energy. This energy
tends to flow from one object or vessel to another, like radio
signals constantly being transmitted and received. Because
of this interconnectedness, the hard lines between self and
other seem to turn hazy, or to disappear altogether. Self is
other, and other is self. Duality is transcended.
   Some authors refer to this state, mode, or realm, as being
one of Mystery (of mysticism), where the “known” of
precise definitions becomes irrelevant, and where rich experiences
that can’t be put adequately into words (or into the
terms of regular logic) reign supreme. It appears to be the
connection to the “Way” of Taoism. For the Christian, it may
well be the Christ connection (“I am the way” . . . ) between
the universal (God) and the particular (human beings). Such
a fluid, transpersonal, aspect of mind or self, cannot be a
slave to individual ego needs.
   Ironically, the true (inner) self is not at all selfish. According
to an inside-out paradigm, the inner self is the source of
what psychology theorist, Alfred Adler, called “social interest.”
The innermost part of self has great capacity for empathy.
It can sense the connection between so-called “self ”
and “other,” since it is not of a mode of consciousness that is
limited to the individual ego.
   This is one way that deep equals wide (and “whole”), in
that empathy involves an ability to open up and relate with
beings (and being-states) beyond an isolated, or dualistic,
self. An Empath (one who can sense things far beyond
themselves) is operating from a deeper part of self than most
people access. Deep equals Wide. Todd believed that Deep
and Whole are, at some point, one and the same.

In Spirit We Trust
Although Dr. Akbar, in The Community of Self, calls the
proper inner governing part of the mind “Will,” many insideout
thinkers use the term “spirit” to designate the innermost
aspect of mind. Even Akbar himself, in his later book, Know
Thyself, tends to refer to the innermost part as being one’s
spirit.
   Deep inside the self is pure energy, which is a modern
science way of saying “spirit.” This is why the belief that we
are energy-based, spiritual, beings first, and physical beings
second, goes hand in hand with the inside-out paradigm. To
access your energy base, you must go deep. To go deep inside,
to the core of self, you must become as pure energy.
   Inside-out belief systems seem to view this energy core, or
spirit, as being an extension of God, rather than as something
outside of God. From an inside-out perspective, trusting in
one’s inner spirit is, for all intents and purposes, the same as
trusting in God. Also, recall the deep equals wide concept.
   The innermost self accesses the broad sweep of God’s hand.
For an interfaith community to be effective in the long
run, it must adopt the inside-out, energy-based, paradigm.
If an outside-in, matter-based, viewpoint is adopted, groups
of people will eventually feel that they must put their ways
in (must convert) the other people who have been outside
of the truth. Instead of a fluid convergence toward common
principles, their differences in religious ideology will matter
too much. The result will be conflict and division.
   While temporary religious tolerance may exist for awhile
under the outside-in and matter-based paradigm, no lasting
appreciation and utilization of religious diversity can be accomplished
under that model. The model community must
have the right model!

No Walls in Allsville
Fortunately, the divisiveness resulting from the various organized
religions disappears as people go deeper into spiritual
understanding and faith. A deeply spiritual Christian has
more in common with a deeply spiritual Muslim than the
deeply spiritual Christian has with a “cookbook Christian.”
   Taking down the walls between organized religions may
be accomplished by cultural/educational processes that take
congregants deeper into the faith experience, into the spirituality
that the religions are intended to serve. Metaphorically
speaking, the Bible story of the sound of the trumpet that
took down the walls of Jericho may have been an allusion
to “hearing” (sensing) the frequencies of deeper spirituality,
the power of spiritual truth. The teaching of deep spiritual
experiences, practices, and principles would be like the
trumpeting that took down the walls of Jericho, only now it
would take down the walls between organized religions, and
would allow for a truly cohesive interfaith community.


from pages 313-322:  

Parking
The open house had been a huge success. The principle of
interconnectedness (and the core virtue of friendliness/love)
was practiced via fellowship. Many of the attending members
met for the first time. They got to know each another
in a very upbeat environment that helped bring out what
psychotherapist and theorist Carl Rogers called “positive regard.”
Roger’s concept of unconditional positive regard—a
version, or variation, of agape love—could best be cultivated
in a climate such as this.
   The atmosphere at the open house was positive enough
to ease people’s minds of any concerns or doubts about the
overall project. It helped them feel comfortable about taking
the risk to develop a deeper sort of trust in one another’s potential,
and to trust each other’s motives. They were inspired
to really believe in Allsville.
   Motives? Intent? The intentionality of an intentional community
does not come from plans alone. Much of intentionality
comes from the honest expression of that which people
long to create. It’s a process of giving a voice to the whispers
within. The emergence of Allsville was not only a matter of
everyone being on the same page; everyone was also on the
same stage, performing their passion play.
   It was symbolically significant that the open house event
was taking place on the actual ground of the dream community.
Everyone could actually see the dream coming true, if
only partially so at this point in time. The event had increased
the overall motivation to work at constructing a physical
community—one that embodies the spiritual principles and
qualities long envisioned by the group.
   Part of spirituality is morality. Much of what the future
citizens of Allsville were longing for was to create a place
where everyone is more likely to “do the right thing” (borrowing
a phrase and title from moviemaker Spike Lee). If
people act morally, then the whole place is a better place
to live—at least as compared to a place where people are
breaking trust, hurting one another, and generally “doing the
wrong thing.”
   But this open house event transcended the standard call to
moral living. There is more to spirituality than just doing the
right thing. The event was spiritual in the sense that it was
an inspiration and a celebration. It put the morale in moral.
   Whether or not the two words—morale and moral—are
linguistically related (although it would be hard to imagine
no language root connection, when the only spelling difference
between the two words is a single letter, an “e”),
there seems to be a close tie between the two, in terms of
meaning.
   In order to maintain moral action, a person needs to “give
a damn.” He or she needs to care about behaving morally, and
about being a moral person of good character (“integrity”).
The goal to be moral is a form of challenge or motivation, the
second core virtue. It requires a positive, going-toward-thelight,
kind of emotional foundation if it is to be sustainable.
   That does not mean everything must be seen as being
rosy; the rosy outlook often begs the opposing image of the
dreaded “thorns.” But it does mean that something positive
and worth striving for needs to be sufficiently sensed. Only
then do we consistently have the motivation to “stay the
course” of moral action and thought. “Sensing something
positive and worth striving for” is the long version of “hope.”
Hope (healthy hope that is grounded in both faith and reality)
helps make good things happen.
   Positive thinking and hope are related to the grace theology
of Christianity. An attitude of grace is an anticipation
of some form of a positive outcome, such as “mercy” or a
“gift.” The anticipation and appreciation of a gift keeps the
individual hopeful enough to work on producing virtue and
morality. From the perspective of grace theology, the skill
of being receptive to God’s grace is the base upon which
true morality is formed. A well-developed attitude of grace
supplements effort.
   It also works the other way around. Some well-placed effort
supplements grace. The two—grace and effort—have a
reciprocal relationship.
   In terms of our core virtues, the grace attitude connects
the fourth core virtue of gift-hood to the second core virtue
of challenge. Without sufficient morale (which implies both
an anticipation and an appreciation of a gift), there would be
insufficient motivation to accept the challenge of doing the
right thing, becoming the right sort of person, or striving for
excellence in general.
   The grace state of mind has two other characteristics that
help maintain morality. Both of these characteristics help increase
morale, but they also contribute to morality in other
ways besides morale per se.
   First, the state of grace includes a sense of mystery or surprise.
The anticipation of life’s gifts involves a readiness to
be pleasantly surprised, whether it is by the big colorfully
wrapped present under the Christmas tree, the breathtaking
beauty of a sunrise, the sweetness of an unexpected kiss, or
the “grace” of a butterfly crossing your path.
   However, we need to be careful about the word anticipation.
Specific positive effects from a specific gift or circumstance
are often the foci of an “anticipation.” This is ordinary
anticipation. This form of anticipation borders on expectation.
It has little to do with the grace attitude. For example,
a person may anticipate the taste of a juicy steak. A person
may anticipate the warmth of a loving relationship. This form
of anticipation also has little to do with mystery or surprise.
   But when anticipation is of such a general nature that it can
best be described as the readiness to be pleasantly surprised
by life, then anticipation becomes a gift in and of itself. The
mind is not merely “looking forward to” the taste of a steak
or the warmth of a loving relationship—it is simply open to
being surprised or amazed. This mind set allows a person
to notice and appreciate lots of beautiful little things in life
that he or she would likely have missed otherwise. Like so
many spiritual states, the surprise aspect of grace involves an
opening up (or increased receptiveness) of the mind.
   As indicated above, anticipation at its best does not equal
(nor closely approximate) “expectation.” A sweet kiss is all
the more tasty when it is unexpected. If expected, the kiss
tends to be taken for granted. The kiss can even become a
source of disappointment if it is not received when expected,
or if the kiss is of lower quality than expected.
   The non-expecting anticipation aspect of grace has the
motivational value of keeping spontaneity and mystery alive;
and of keeping monotony, boredom, and dread in check.
Expectation is a closed-mind state, whereas an anticipation
based on the appreciation/valuing of surprise involves
openness.
   The surprise mind set we are talking about here is the
“little s” surprise. It’s more contemplative than fun. To go
around being constantly surprised in the “big S” manner, is
to act like you are on cocaine. It simply isn’t sustainable. Nor
is it preferable, even if it were sustainable, because it would
create a distorted, imbalanced, view of life.
   Euthymia is the psychological word for a normal positive
mood. That is the mood state which goes with the “little s”
surprise . Euphoria is the “big S” surprise. Some euphoria is
fine, but too much of it makes a pathology of joy, and makes
a distortion of openness.
   Euphoria tends to be an overcompensation by a closed
mind that opens up too fast. It is the mood equivalent of the
eye’s pupils dilating excessively when a person first walks
into a dark room. It’s an attempt to see, but it doesn’t really
work. A large degree of dilation is a compensation for lack
of light. If a person’s mood, like a person’s pupils, has a compensatory
openness, it is not a sustainable, nor useful, form
of openness.
   Having said that, the normal contamination of soul or spirit
is the reflexive habit of closing the mind. When in doubt, we
tend to close the mind and pretend to “see” or to “know.”
Trouble is, this is a pseudo-knowledge which is analogous
to breathing stale air. It is “thought,” but not real “thinking.”
Real thinking requires perceptiveness and fresh insight.
Real thinking involves a sustainable sort of openness (which
bears a fair amount of the fruit of “creativity”).
   David Bohm called such open thought “proprioceptive
thought.” The proprioceptive system is the system that allows
a person’s body to “know” where its parts are in relation
to one another, and in relation to the things around it in the
physical environment. When proprioceptive awareness fails
us, we bite our tongues or run into things or blow out the
ACLs of our knees.
   In general, the mind and spirit need to loosen up and open
up in order to grow and to become more truly aware and/or
intelligent. “Little s” surprise helps us open the mind in a
useful and sustainable way.
   To the extent that “openness” or “opening up” involves
letting go of any attachments which have, in the past, prevented
a person from opening up, then the Spiritual Principle
of Lightness (and its corresponding core virtue of simplicity
and peace) seems to enter into the morale/morality “chemical
compound.” The attitude of grace is related to the Spiritual
Principle of Lightness.
   In turn, Lightness facilitates mystery. Next, both mystery
and grace facilitate morale. Finally, morale facilitates
morality.
   But the formula is still not complete. The attitude, or
“thinking habit,” of grace has a second major aspect. It
involves a self image of what Carl Rogers called “unconditional
positive regard.” To feel loved or valuable in an unconditional
way is a means to help maintain morale. It allows
the individual to accept himself or herself, no matter how
bad he or she messes up. The person may still want to do
better the next time, but at least they don’t beat themselves
up in the meantime.
   While the idea of “earning” or “making” something also
has significant motivational value, it tends to leave its participant
dependent on two outcomes: 1. being able to perform
the job, and, 2. getting “paid” (in one manner or another)
once the job is completed.
   This leaves self esteem at the mercy of factors other than
one’s true potential. Just as the perfect can become the enemy
of the good, so can the actual become the enemy of
one’s potential.
   Even when a person mistakenly pursues something for
which he or she is not naturally gifted, and, as a consequence,
fails miserably (more or less proving that he or she
doesn’t have much potential in that specific area), he or she
still has plenty of potential in other areas. When the individual’s
pool of potential is eclipsed by poor outcomes or by a
sign of personal limitations, it creates a demotivated state
that unnecessarily limits his or her actualization of potential—
including the actualization of virtues and morality.
   Again, the problem of being dependent upon an outcome
is that it involves a closed state of mind. One solution to this
problem (of an overly closed state of mind) is unconditional
positive self-regard.
   Unconditional positive self-regard is related to openness.
Where there is openness, there tends to be unconditional
positive self-regard. And where there is unconditional positive
self-regard, there tends to be openness. Stated differently,
unconditional positive self-regard and openness seem
to be “doors” that open up to one another.
   We often associate morality with judgement or decision-
making. Using good judgement, we can turn away,
cut off, or “close out” bad, unhealthy, options. This version
of morality seems to lean toward focalized attention and
closed-mindedness.
   However, the spiritual “well” from which sustainable morality
flows, comes from a state of receptiveness and openness.
Far from closing out, it opens into. Spirituality does
leave behind (by outgrowing, or by transcending), but spirituality
doesn’t achieve growth by closing out—at least closing
out is not its main, or preferred, way of facilitating growth.
Some thinkers may argue that grace theology can compromise
the “responsibility” part of the Spiritual Principle of
Responsible Creating. They say that grace theology enables
the individual to deny or to minimize their own accountability
in regards to the outcomes. It is argued that whatever happens,
the grace-user receives the reward of feeling good (or
at least feeling okay) about themselves. This is thought to
create a kind of disincentive for making correct choices.
   In standard Christian theology, for example, grace can
“save” you at any point short of death. Even if you open up
and receive the free gift of grace only a split second before
you die, you will still go to heaven.
   Some argue that it is totally unfair that a scoundrel can repent
on his or her death bed, receive grace, and enter heaven
the same as a person who had been a saint all of his or her
life. The scoundrel is thought to have gotten more bang for
his/her grace-buck. This soul repented little (not as often as
a righteous person) and late. Yet they get the same reward.
The notion of grace’s exemption of the consequences of sin
is said to be problematic, because it leads to a lack of moral
discipline.
   This argument may have some merit. Nonetheless, the
consented-upon philosophy of Allsville is aligned with grace
theology. Despite the fact that it is a real challenge to become
a moral person or a moral culture, despite the fact that
challenge generally involves a great deal of effort, and despite
the fact that personal accountability is important, the
effort-bound version of moral discipline is given a back seat
to grace.
   Why? Because grace tilts the mind toward openness and
whole-mind activity, whereas effort and control tilts the mind
toward part-mind activity. In the long run, grace, openness,
and whole-mind priority will produce more “responsible”
behavior than will the forcing of oneself to make the right
choices.
   In fact, being overly responsible ends up being irresponsible,
because it tends to create a psychological side effect
of self doubt, and/or false pride. Self doubt and false pride
then become contaminants in the culture, preventing it from
becoming an optimal one. The release of such contaminants
into the culture is just as irresponsible as pouring harmful
chemicals into the water supply.
   Yes, a leaning toward over-control makes for either self
doubt, false pride, or a flip-flopping between the two. The
self doubt or false pride often lives in the shadows of self
awareness, rather than being easily seen and “owned” by the
individual. This makes it difficult to find these two contaminants.
Not only is it difficult for others to find them, but it is
hard for oneself to find his or her own locus of contamination.
Self doubt and false pride hide in the shadows.
   These shadow-lurkers are analogous to the lactic acid that
a runner builds up when he/she exceeds his/her sustainable
pace. In the long run, forced responsibility clouds the mind,
and interferes with its overall ability to make good decisions—
just as lactic acid deadens the muscles and interferes
with the runner’s performance toward the end of the race.
Like an effective distance runner who knows how to properly
pace, how to recover, and how replenish the body, Allsville
takes the long view as regards responsibility.
   All three of the motivational factors of the grace thinking
habit discussed above contribute to a positive bias toward
openness. The general sense of morale offered by grace helps
keep the mind happy and comfortable enough to take on necessary
risks and challenges. A sense of mystery opens up the
mind to explore—to contemplate the spontaneous unfoldings
of life. A sense of unconditional love, or unconditional
positive regard, helps keep the mind from being insecure and
self-defeating. A person without this unconditional aspect of
grace is more likely to say to himself or herself, “I have nothing
to lose, so it’s okay to go ahead and be immoral, or to be
of bad character.”
   To put it simply, it’s easier to be virtuous and moral when
you’re happy! If you develop the art of receiving gifts—including
the gift of your own unique existence—you are more
likely in the long run to meet the challenge of creating a
virtuous and moral life. An attitude of grace greatly assists
in mastering the Spiritual Principle of Responsible Creating,
and in creating the healthy characteristic (or “core virtue”)
of challenge in Allsville.
   As it turns out, the open house celebration put the second
core virtue (and its corresponding Spiritual Principle of Responsible
Creating) in its place in two ways.
   First, it acknowledged the quality of having a manifested
place to live—a place in which the community takes actual
form. Challenge had a place to park. It had a “parking place.”
That certainly was something worth celebrating.
   Secondly, the open house festivities acknowledged that
the manifestation was primarily a gift. It wasn’t merely an
accomplishment. This puts accomplishment and challenge
“in its place”—behind gift-hood (the fourth core virtue, and
the corresponding Spiritual Principle of Appreciation), behind
the open-minded wonder of true awareness (the first
core virtue, and its corresponding Spiritual Principle of
Whole-to-part), behind love (the third core virtue, and its
corresponding Spiritual Principle of Interconnectedness),
and behind simply receiving (invoking the fifth core virtue
of simplicity and its corresponding Spiritual Principle of
“Lightness”).
   Does this devalue the core virtue of challenge? Certainly
not. While challenge and hard work may be transcended by
love, thankfulness, awareness, and peace, it is (to use Hegel’s
and Ken Wilber’s concept of “transcend and include”) also
“included” in the whole shebang.
   Challenge and self-mastery help make all those things
happen. They are vital to the well-being of the community.
The folks at Allsville had every right to proudly and confidently
embrace the challenge that they were already starting
to fulfill. The open house proved to be a good vehicle toward
that end.
    Speaking of vehicles, the open house also brought something
else to the planners’ awareness: “We need to think
about parking lots. What if it had rained? We would have
a lot of cars stuck in the mud!” Also, even the few cars that
will accompany the frequently-scheduled Council meetings
will likely create a significant hardship to the Hugelhoffs.
Sandy will get ready to go to the store one day, only to find
out that fifteen or so cars are blocking her in. The down side
of manifestation of Allsville as a physical reality is that it
creates a parking problem!


from pages 338-340: 

Sylvia and others understood that Allsville, a microcosm
of civilization, would, like whole civilizations, only prosper
in a sustainable way if the natural “insides” of each
citizen matched the outside culture. Historically, most great
civilizations died of a combination of over-expansion and
over-assimilation. As the system became more and more differentiated
and codified, the union lost its sense of meaning,
and the participants lacked the morale to maintain the challenge
and the cooperation needed to grow. The civilization
no longer had sufficient meaning for the participants.
   Along these same lines of thought, Daniel Quinn, in Beyond
Civilization, reviews evidence that the Mayans may
have simply walked away from their highly developed civilization.
It wasn’t working anymore, so, according to Quinn,
they walked back into the jungle, in order to resume tribal
living. Whether or not this explains the fall of the Mayan empire,
Quinn’s theory that civilization can outlive its usefulness
to the human being—no longer sufficiently addressing
the physical and spiritual hunger within each person—seems
to have merit.
   More is not always more, even if it is on a grand scale of
an entire civilization. Sometimes less is more. And sometimes
simply walking away from a civilization may be preferable
to continuing to “play the game” as it is set up in that
civilization.
   As once-great civilizations began to fail, their lack of
growth quickly turned into going backwards, similar to what
often happens when a sports team is “sitting on a lead” in a
game. There seems to be some truth in the popular football
adage: “Prevent defense prevents you from winning.” As civilizations
outgrow the freshness of meaningful expression—
as they become disconnected from the individual spirits, and
from the collective spirit, of the people—they lose momentum.
Soon thereafter, they implode from the weight of too
much (external, “spirit-dystonic”) matter that the system
generates in an attempt to sustain itself. The more matter the
civilization adds in order to try to prop itself up, the greater
the implosion. The bigger they are, the harder they fall.
   Another way of saying “spirit-dystonic matter” is “outsidein.”
Ironically, the more a social union works to sustain itself
in an outside-in manner (in which the spirit is not inspired or
satisfied) the less sustainable the social union becomes.
   Even though this little civilization of Allsville was just now
moving through the birth canal, so to speak, the thoughtful
members realized that it was imperative that they keep the
project anchored in the spirit. From an historical perspective,
more often than not the exuberance and the freshness
of the early part of the journey is so strong that the members
of an emerging society begin to take that positive passion
for granted, mistakenly assuming that it is a more-or-less
guaranteed (and automatic) part of their identity, rather than
anticipating that there could easily be a time soon when they
all forget why they bothered to come together.
   Accordingly, much of the work of the orientation phase
would be to help the participants find themselves—their
true selves. This self awareness doesn’t come easily in an
outside-in culture like the one in which we have been participating
up ‘til now. But with this formidable challenge of
trying to inspire people who are suffering from self-alienation
brought about by the modern world comes a perk. If
the training helps the participant increase even a little bit
of self awareness, then the training will seem successful,
whether or not the participant chooses to become a citizen
of Allsville.
   In fact, when viewing the purpose of the training in this
light, it could not help but be successful. Even those who decline
the opportunity to become a citizen could have something
positive to say about Allsville to outsiders. “The lost
sales may become our best salespersons” blurted Sylvia as
she thought out loud. She and the other council members
got excited about planning this first phase of the Function of
Matching and Development.
   The council agreed to give the green light for Drew to
assemble a task force of educators who would draft a lesson
plan for the orientation program. The program would be
called WOW, “Welcome to Well-being.” The council room
could be used as a classroom for the first few groups of
students.


from pages 402-404: 

4. Policy: Work with the educing of mind, with the nurturing
of “gifts.”

The FSDM will work in concert with the Function of Matching
and Personal Development. Social well-being seems
largely determined by how well individual potentials, or
“gifts,” are identified, developed, and used. Any form of social
regulation or “social decision-making” that fails to work
with the function of matching (of matching gifts to niches)
and personal development, will not achieve a very high level
of social regulation, and will not result in sustainably good
decisions. This is why the FSDM must work in concert with
the FSMPD.
   Gift assessment and utilization is at the heart of utilizing
human resources. The proper utilization of human resources,
in turn, highly correlates with the proper utilization of nonhuman
resources, such as: energy, water, land, air, and the
ecosystems upon which humans depend.
   In a lower right Integral quad sort of way, the community
is nothing more than a system that arranges and utilizes
resources. The human resources which are saved by the
proper development and use of gifts (human potentials and
aptitudes) increase the community’s capacity to effectively
utilize nonhuman resources. The human gifts are applied toward
stewardship of the land, etc. Conversely, it may be said,
“Waste a human and you waste the land.”
   For this reason, the overall resource allocation and utilization
“system” is primarily a human system. When the community’s
larger (sociopolitical and socioeconomic) system
fails to realize this, and focuses too much on nonhuman
things, then it tends to become dehumanizing, as well as inefficient
at utilizing resources in general.
   It’s not that we humans are worth much more than the
earth and its creatures. This is not another promotion of
anthropocentrism. And we certainly can’t afford to see humankind’s
relationship with the earth in a win/lose kind of
way. We must strive for a win/win relationship with Mother
Earth.
   The reason that a lot of attention must be given to developing
human gifts is that so much of the “earthwork” comes
from human beings. We need to give a high priority to the
development of human minds and human souls because
we—like it or not—seem to be in a position of having a lot
to do with the cosmic outcome. We are not better. We are
more responsible. That’s why it’s so important for us to adopt
the Spiritual Principle of Responsible Creating.

Practice: Ongoing, and frequent, dialogue
between the FSDM and the FMPD.
The council will meet once every two weeks with teachers
from the orientation classes of the WOW program, and with
teachers from each of six developmental levels: preschool,
elementary, middle, high school, college and adult education
(the LEAD program) . The council will also meet monthly
with the FMPD’s “Vocational Coordinator” (the “VC”), and
with the “Avocation Coordinator” (the “AC”).
   The VC will ensure that niches match up with the changing
conditions of the community, as represented by the council,
and will inform the council about problems or developments
in the niches of the social system. Once the Function of
Placement and Occupation Development is established, the
“FOPOD” director will also be included in the meeting.
   The AC will report on the “state of constructive free time
use” in Allsville. The AC helps make life “cool” at Allsville!
The AC has a lot to do with morale.
Both the VC and the AC will also submit brief reports
for the Towne Pray-er editor to include or paraphrase in the
newspaper and newscast.
   The purpose of these meetings between the two subsystems
of education and government (plus FOPOD later on) is
threefold: 1. to allow the FSDM to stay informed about issues
and concepts as the FMPD moves forward and accumulates
more and more experience, 2. to be ready to make decisions
that will address those issues or initiatives, and 3. to offer the
FMPD any ideas and/or information from the perspective of
social policies that may assist in educational planning, etc.